Is Silva still the P4P #1 Fighter?

Cole1186Cole1186 Posts: 3,721Free
edited July 2013 in UFC
New P4P list says this:

#1 Jon Jones
#2 GSP
#3 Anderson
#4 Jose Aldo

What are your guys thoughts on this updated list since Silva got dethroned?

Is Silva still the P4P #1 Fighter?

Sign in to vote!
This is a public poll: others will see what you voted for.
image

Comments

  • 12er12er Posts: 10,842Free
    Anderson is still above GSP but below Jones

    It should go

    1 Jones
    2 Weidman
    3 Anderson
    4 Aldo
    5 Cain

    That's going to rustle some Jimmies. I can't wait to read the replies.
  • carnages41carnages41 Posts: 36,269Free
    Anderson is still above GSP but below Jones
    12er said:

    It should go

    1 Jones
    2 Weidman
    3 Anderson
    4 Aldo
    5 Cain

    That's going to rustle some Jimmies. I can't wait to read the replies.
    The truth hurts

    "Anderon below the guy he got KO'd by? Ridiculous!"

    "GSP not in the top 5!? Troll! Its not like he outweighs his opponents and beats them in the least dominant fashion!"
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Last one to post wins- Winner
    UFC Forum Fight Camp- Winner
    UFC PREDICTIONS TOURNAMENT 5 - unofficial winner
    image
  • ultimatefightingchampultimatefightingchamp Posts: 27,350Free
    No - Jones is p4p #1
    Obviously Jones is #1
    image
  • FroZeNFroZeN Posts: 4,762Free
    Anderson is still above GSP but below Jones
    "WW has been the most stacked division for years!"
    "Dan Hardy was legit!"
    "Josh Koscheck is still dangerous with one eye!"
    "I bathed in GSPs vaseline!"
    OFFICIAL UFC FORUM BLACKBELT
  • 12er12er Posts: 10,842Free
    edited July 2013
    Anderson is still above GSP but below Jones

    It should go

    1 Jones
    2 Weidman
    3 Anderson
    4 Aldo
    5 Cain

    That's going to rustle some Jimmies. I can't wait to read the replies.

    12er said:

    It should go

    1 Jones
    2 Weidman
    3 Anderson
    4 Aldo
    5 Cain

    That's going to rustle some Jimmies. I can't wait to read the replies.
    The truth hurts

    "Anderon below the guy he got KO'd by? Ridiculous!"

    "GSP not in the top 5!? Troll! Its not like he outweighs his opponents and beats them in the least dominant fashion!"
    I agree with you.
    Post edited by 12er on
  • AmerimanAmeriman Posts: 2,069Free
    Anderson is still above GSP but below Jones

    It should go

    1 Jones
    2 Weidman
    3 Anderson
    4 Aldo
    5 Cain

    Lmao! Brilliant...
    Boston threw me a god damn beating. DOOMGOAT REIGNS SUPREME
  • Epiqu1nEpiqu1n Posts: 1,473Free
    Mighty Mouse is p4p #1, but i don't see that poll option there probably just a mistake. And if it wasn't you should delete your account, and never come back.
    List of GOAT Fighters

    1. Michael McDonald
    2. Nick Diaz
    3. Demetrious Johnson
    4. Matt Brown
    5. Rashad Evans
    6. JDS
    7. Joe Lauzon
    8. Patster
    9. Carnage
    10. 12er
    11. LayDownDead
    12. Diego Brandao
    13. Papy Abedi
    14. Tom Brady
    15. Russell Wilson
    16. Manhoef
    17. Scott Jorgensen
    18. Elias Silverio
    19. Fabio Maldonado
    20. Louis Smolka

  • WarWestWarWest Órale VatoPosts: 33,731Free
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    It should go:

    Silva
    Diaz
    Everybody else
    GSP
    The Cal Ripken Of GSP hatin'
    Arch Bishop Of Anti-GSP
    The Stockton Hater
    209's So Fine
  • GoToGuyGoToGuy Posts: 5,361Free
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    Yes.
    image

  • PunchBagPunchBag Posts: 7,824Free
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    he is still the p4p number 1, a single loss wont change that, if he loses the rematch then yea he isnt p4p 1 anymore
    "Believe in the beard"
    I bet against THE KING and he smashed my little gonads into oblivion
    image
    image


  • BeanslegendBeanslegend Posts: 806Free
    Anderson is where he currently belongs at #3
    Silva has had an easy ride in a crappy division. Middleweight is a laughing joke with so many cans in the top 10 its pathetic.
  • classicboxerclassicboxer Posts: 11,823Free
    How do you guys judge P4P? I look at every physical aspect, speed, strength, reflexes, etc., and combine that with results of fights. Now, Anderson just got KOed, and has a suspect chin. He's no longer in the discussion for me.
    Oakland, CA: Raiders, A's, Warriors
  • mutharashamutharasha Posts: 700Free
    No - Jones is p4p #1
    why is he still deserving of No.1?! He got KTFO by a guy outside the P4P top 10? It's not a lifetime achievement award. It's who is the best fighter in the world RIGHT NOW. To use boxing as an example, No.1 P4P Pacquiao gets KO by No.6 Marquez. It was a very close fight, but, at the end of the day, Marquez won, proving that he is the better man atm. Pac drops to 6. Marquez jumps to 3. How can Anderson still be considered the best in the world after a resounding KO loss. Heres mine:

    1. Jones
    2. GSP
    3. Aldo
    4.Cain
    5. Henderson
    6. Weidman
    7. Silva
    8. Barao
    9. Cruz
    10. Belfort

    Anderson drops because he is not what he once was and it was proven last week.
    #StillRallyingForMarkHunt

    UFC 160 = the night Kiwis will fly.

    The Kuddles Krew yo - Vitor ''The Phenom'' Belfort, Chael Sonnen, TJ Dillashaw, Frankie ''The Answer'' Edgar, Pat ''HD'' Barry, Erik Perez, Darrell Montague, Robert Drysdale, Charles ''Do Bronx'' Oliveira, Thiago Silva

    FABIO!
    image

    Survivor Series 1 Runner Up (boy crie :'((((((((( )


  • Yesterdays_HeroYesterdays_Hero Posts: 23,619Free

    why is he still deserving of No.1?! He got KTFO by a guy outside the P4P top 10? It's not a lifetime achievement award. It's who is the best fighter in the world RIGHT NOW. To use boxing as an example, No.1 P4P Pacquiao gets KO by No.6 Marquez. It was a very close fight, but, at the end of the day, Marquez won, proving that he is the better man atm. Pac drops to 6. Marquez jumps to 3. How can Anderson still be considered the best in the world after a resounding KO loss. Heres mine:

    1. Jones
    2. GSP
    3. Aldo
    4.Cain
    5. Henderson
    6. Weidman
    7. Silva
    8. Barao
    9. Cruz
    10. Belfort

    Anderson drops because he is not what he once was and it was proven last week.

    What Henderson is that? Neither of them deserves to be #5
  • mutharashamutharasha Posts: 700Free
    No - Jones is p4p #1

    why is he still deserving of No.1?! He got KTFO by a guy outside the P4P top 10? It's not a lifetime achievement award. It's who is the best fighter in the world RIGHT NOW. To use boxing as an example, No.1 P4P Pacquiao gets KO by No.6 Marquez. It was a very close fight, but, at the end of the day, Marquez won, proving that he is the better man atm. Pac drops to 6. Marquez jumps to 3. How can Anderson still be considered the best in the world after a resounding KO loss. Heres mine:

    1. Jones
    2. GSP
    3. Aldo
    4.Cain
    5. Henderson
    6. Weidman
    7. Silva
    8. Barao
    9. Cruz
    10. Belfort

    Anderson drops because he is not what he once was and it was proven last week.

    What Henderson is that? Neither of them deserves to be #5
    Bendo. Like it or not, he's still winning fights against the best LW's (one of the best division) in the world. He's scraping them but still getting the nod
    #StillRallyingForMarkHunt

    UFC 160 = the night Kiwis will fly.

    The Kuddles Krew yo - Vitor ''The Phenom'' Belfort, Chael Sonnen, TJ Dillashaw, Frankie ''The Answer'' Edgar, Pat ''HD'' Barry, Erik Perez, Darrell Montague, Robert Drysdale, Charles ''Do Bronx'' Oliveira, Thiago Silva

    FABIO!
    image

    Survivor Series 1 Runner Up (boy crie :'((((((((( )


  • kapstkapst ChicagolandPosts: 2,660Free
    Anderson is where he currently belongs at #3

    How do you guys judge P4P? I look at every physical aspect, speed, strength, reflexes, etc., and combine that with results of fights. Now, Anderson just got KOed, and has a suspect chin. He's no longer in the discussion for me.

    I'm guessing most people don't use any logic at all. They just use p4p as an excuse to hype up their favorite fighters..

    Silva was still a "finisher", so none of his actual attributes actually matter..

    How do you guys judge P4P? I look at every physical aspect, speed, strength, reflexes, etc., and combine that with results of fights. Now, Anderson just got KOed, and has a suspect chin. He's no longer in the discussion for me.

    I'm guessing most people don't use any logic at all. They just use p4p as an excuse to hype up their favorite fighters. For most, bias is the only attribute that matters in p4p discussions.. Truth..
  • WarWestWarWest Órale VatoPosts: 33,731Free
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    kapst said:

    How do you guys judge P4P? I look at every physical aspect, speed, strength, reflexes, etc., and combine that with results of fights. Now, Anderson just got KOed, and has a suspect chin. He's no longer in the discussion for me.

    I'm guessing most people don't use any logic at all. They just use p4p as an excuse to hype up their favorite fighters..

    Silva was still a "finisher", so none of his actual attributes actually matter..

    How do you guys judge P4P? I look at every physical aspect, speed, strength, reflexes, etc., and combine that with results of fights. Now, Anderson just got KOed, and has a suspect chin. He's no longer in the discussion for me.

    I'm guessing most people don't use any logic at all. They just use p4p as an excuse to hype up their favorite fighters. For most, bias is the only attribute that matters in p4p discussions.. Truth..
    Interesting Jekyll and Hyde
    The Cal Ripken Of GSP hatin'
    Arch Bishop Of Anti-GSP
    The Stockton Hater
    209's So Fine
  • S6XStringzS6XStringz Posts: 1,067Free
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    Silva is still number 1. He was number by a landslide before, why would he drop a spot because of one loss? We wait till the rematch and if he loses in any way shape or form, even if he dominates but gets disqualified somehow we then drop him a spot.
  • idrankyourbeeridrankyourbeer Sony: "We made VCRs too. Play in our world. Watch tv in theirs!"Posts: 21,121Free
    edited July 2013
    Anderson is where he currently belongs at #3
    gsp
    jones
    silva
    aldo
    Post edited by idrankyourbeer on
    Just givin out the D
    Roy Nelson - Devouring the competition and pissing out excellence
    I want to die peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather. not screaming and yelling like the passengers in his car
    image
  • Cole1186Cole1186 Posts: 3,721Free
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    He'll jump back to #1 on the official rankings after December 28. I still think he's #1 now but it's not what everyone is listing him at, so he'll just have to KO Wiedman to prove it.
    image
  • OmahaOutcastOmahaOutcast Posts: 281Free
    1. Jones
    2. Silva
    3. Aldo
    4. Cain

    Not sure where I'd put Weidman, either right above Silva or right below him
    Jake Ellenberger > GSP

    Robbie Lawler = GOAT

    Scott Jorgensen #1 favorite bantamweight
  • idrankyourbeeridrankyourbeer Sony: "We made VCRs too. Play in our world. Watch tv in theirs!"Posts: 21,121Free
    Anderson is where he currently belongs at #3
    gsp
    jones
    silva
    aldo
    winner of cain/jds

    it is how it is
    Just givin out the D
    Roy Nelson - Devouring the competition and pissing out excellence
    I want to die peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather. not screaming and yelling like the passengers in his car
    image
  • _Finish_Him__Finish_Him_ Posts: 11,585Free
    Anderson is still above GSP but below Jones
    #1 Jones
    #2 Silva
    #3 Aldo
    .....




    ......
    #199 GSP!
    When it's about fighting and not humping... -.-
    image
    image
    Predicition League Record: 39-15, Prediction League Record: 6-1, ***Camp League Record***: 9-2
    OFFICIAL UFC PREDICTION TOURNAMENT 7 WINNER
    http://forums.ufcfightclub.com/discussion/147741/michelle-waterson-appreciation-thread/p1
    http://forums.ufcfightclub.com/discussion/147932/that-80-s-90-s-thread-bittersweet-memories/p1
    image







  • MachidaPowerMachidaPower Serial Chillin.Posts: 1,963Free
    edited July 2013
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    he sure got made a fool out of, but hes still.... by far.... the most dangerous man in the UFC.

    id bet that anderson silva could FINISH cain. any disbelievers?
    Post edited by MachidaPower on
    the buffer 180... best move in the UFC.

    http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=169_1364680421

    image

    "Ameriman is the P4P greatest poster of all time, and he would never welch on a sigbet." [sic]

    "I took wanderleisilva101's MMA knowledge to the back of the throat and I loved it! P.S Chael will get destroyed by Wand too!"

    Miesha Nose.
  • Weidman_the_GOATWeidman_the_GOAT Posts: 2,758Free
    1) Weidman
    2) JDS
    3) Jones
    4) Aldo
    5) Gsp
    image


    image



    Welchers:
    Bluesy(sig)
    Identity(poop eating bet)



    Weidman | Belfort | Sanchez | Gus | Aldo | Maia | JDS | Pettis | Shogun | Glover | Jacare | Machida | Silva | Cub | Mcgregor | Manuwa


    Poop eating bets: 1-0

    Gustaffson is the Real 205 champ right now.
    Gus- 1, 2, 3, 4.
  • BanutuBanutu Posts: 619Free
    Anderson is where he currently belongs at #3
    how can someone rate this guy #1 P4P after getting embarrassingly KTFO....
    image
  • MachidaPowerMachidaPower Serial Chillin.Posts: 1,963Free
    Yes - Anderson is still p4p #1
    Banutu said:

    how can someone rate this guy #1 P4P after getting embarrassingly KTFO....

    because he basically did it to himself. anderson is a great fighter. he knew what time it was.
    the buffer 180... best move in the UFC.

    http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=169_1364680421

    image

    "Ameriman is the P4P greatest poster of all time, and he would never welch on a sigbet." [sic]

    "I took wanderleisilva101's MMA knowledge to the back of the throat and I loved it! P.S Chael will get destroyed by Wand too!"

    Miesha Nose.
Sign In or Register to comment.