Jump to content

Dana white "edgar is the #2 p4p fighter in the world"


King_Can

Recommended Posts

And? There is no criteria for P4P' date=' I could care less who is ranked where.[/quote']

 

I believe rings broke it down as such

 

-level of compation

-proformance

-win streak

-size of compation (as in changing weightclasses)

 

This is ment for boxing but mma hold all the key things aswell that goes into a boxing p4p ranking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I believe rings broke it down as such

 

-level of compation

-proformance

-win streak

-size of compation (as in changing weightclasses)

 

This is ment for boxing but mma hold all the key things aswell that goes into a boxing p4p ranking

 

The problem is that it's all opinionated, so I don't put too much emphasis on it. I think weightlifting is the only real sport where P4P truly apllies.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

even though i dislike Frankie' date=' I've been saying it for a long time that Frankie is better P4P then GSP and Jon Jones.

 

However, Aldo has done more in his division then Edgar has at 155, so I still have Aldo over Frankie.[/quote']

 

Doesn't Aldo only have 3 wins in the UFC?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The problem is that it's all opinionated' date=' so I don't put too much emphasis on it. I think weightlifting is the only real sport where P4P truly apllies.[/quote']

 

First u said there is not criterias...well i provided them now u say well its all opinionated...dont give me that....its P4P just like how everything else is based off opinions

 

U have a gf (i assume) be cuz her OPINIONS of u are good....opinions matter sometimes and in p4p they do aswell

 

Bet ull be in the next thread claiming gsp is p4p better then silva

Link to comment
Share on other sites

First u said there is not criterias...well i provided them now u say well its all opinionated...dont give me that....its P4P just like how everything else is based off opinions

 

U have a gf (i assume) be cuz her OPINIONS of u are good....opinions matter sometimes and in p4p they do aswell

 

Bet ull be in the next thread claiming gsp is p4p better then silva

 

All I did was criticize the criteria you gave. Those are not official, just what you use. There is no real criteria. I could choose the guy I think is best at video games, would I be wrong? Nope, and no one would be able to prove me wrong. It makes no sense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

even though i dislike Frankie' date=' I've been saying it for a long time that Frankie is better P4P then GSP and Jon Jones.

 

However, Aldo has done more in his division then Edgar has at 155, so I still have Aldo over Frankie.[/quote']

 

Frankie

 

Gray

Bjpenn X2

Sean sherk

Jim miller

Mark bocek

Hermas franca

Tyson griffin

Spencer fisher??

 

Aldo

 

Kenflo

mark hominick

Urijah faber

Mike brown

Manny gambuyan

Brookings???

Cub swanson???

 

I give it to frankie with him being the same size as aldo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All I did was criticize the criteria you gave. Those are not official' date=' just what you use. There is no real criteria. I could choose the guy I think is best at video games, would I be wrong? Nope, and no one would be able to prove me wrong. It makes no sense.[/quote']

 

Thats not my criteria its RINGS so it has weight

 

Its official for boxing yes...in which can be applyed to mma based off the idea that mma ranking and weightclasses are built in a common way

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats not my criteria its RINGS so it has weight

 

Its official for boxing yes...in which can be applyed to mma based off the idea that mma ranking and weightclasses are built in a common way

 

I don't think it's official in boxing either......they had a Pacqiauo-Mayweather P4P debate just 3 weeks ago. If you think it's legit, that's fine. I don't, and probably never will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not official in boxing. Ring Magazine takes a vote and then says one boxer is #1 P4P' date=' but there is no way to prove it. It's just for fun.[/quote']

 

Why u ruin my fun with ur truth...i never troll and u ruined it for me man

 

Im not go at it..he was not getting mad...its not my thing

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think it's official in boxing either......they had a Pacqiauo-Mayweather P4P debate just 3 weeks ago. If you think it's legit' date=' that's fine. I don't, and probably never will.[/quote']

 

On the real dude its not legit....i think rings has it down right and ppl who take p4p ranking (not u) should uses the method of rings cuz it works the best with opinions

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...