Jump to content

Aldo vs Edgar: not even a close fight


sam_thetrumen
 Share

Recommended Posts

I mean Aldo will make Edgar looks like a joke. I wouldnot say Edgar has no chance' date=' but that chance may only exist in theory.[/quote']

 

who exactly has Aldo beat florian,faber, hominick,Edger has beat Penn twice Maynard, Sherk,Miller and arguably Henderson in the second fight, it's clear who has fought better fighters.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

who exactly has Aldo beat florian' date='faber, hominick,Edger has beat Penn twice Maynard, Sherk,Miller and arguably Henderson in the second fight, it's clear who has fought better fighters.[/quote']

 

Aldo

Florian-always top LW

Faber-once P4P

Hominick-good FW

Mendez-previously undefeated FW

 

 

Edgar

Penn-Once P4P/UFC champ

maynard-who has he beat? florian? arent you saying hes trash in ur post?

sherk-????????

miller-back in the dark ages he beat him

 

 

he hasnt beat henderson

 

 

they both have fought top comp in there divisions...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Aldo

Florian-always top LW

Faber-once P4P

Hominick-good FW

Mendez-previously undefeated FW

 

 

Edgar

Penn-Once P4P/UFC champ

maynard-who has he beat? florian? arent you saying hes trash in ur post?

sherk-????????

miller-back in the dark ages he beat him

 

 

he hasnt beat henderson

 

 

they both have fought top comp in there divisions...

 

in no way was Faber ever P4P he'e lost twice to Mike Brown and Sherk is 36-4 with is only losses being to GSP,Hughes,Penn and Edger

Link to comment
Share on other sites

who exactly has Aldo beat florian' date='faber, hominick,Edger has beat Penn twice Maynard, Sherk,Miller and arguably Henderson in the second fight, it's clear who has fought better fighters.[/quote']

 

Yes, Edgar had beaten alot of guys, but arguably. I mean, arguably Sonnen beat Silva. Aldo differ himself from Edgar by beating every opponent decisively.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

in no way was Faber ever P4P he'e lost twice to Mike Brown and Sherk is 36-4 with is only losses being to GSP' date='Hughes,Penn and Edger[/quote']

 

faber was never P4P?

 

wow your retarded....at the peak of his reign he was

just like torres was derp :rolleyes:

 

sherk hasnt been relevant for a LONG time....

 

to say aldo has beat nobody is retarded...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

faber was never P4P?

 

wow your retarded....at the peak of his reign he was

just like torres was derp :rolleyes:

 

sherk hasnt been relevant for a LONG time....

 

to say aldo has beat nobody is retarded...

 

Who did he beat to be P4P or Torres for that matter thats like saying Tim Sylvia was P4P, yeah to you relized the people that he beat sucked.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No one beats Edgar easy' date=' he puts up a very good fight against every person they put in front of him, and he has faced the best of the best at LW. He is going to test Aldo big time, to say this fight is not even close is just showing your lack of knowledge when it comes to MMA.[/quote']

To me, Edgar didnot bring any threat to Bendo, donot you think it is a kind of easy fight?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who did he beat to be P4P or Torres for that matter thats like saying Tim Sylvia was P4P' date=' yeah to you relized the people that he beat sucked.[/quote']

 

buttchin was never p4p

 

http://www.411mania.com/MMA/columns/87287/411//s-MMA-Rankings-10.09.08:-Pound-For-Pound.htm

 

http://www.scoresreport.com/2008/10/27/mma-pound-for-pound-rankings/

 

^^^faber/torres

 

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/260645-september-pound-for-pound-rankings-the-song-remains-the-same

 

http://www.profighting-fans.com/rankings/pound-for-pound_020709.html

 

^^^^torres for a second year

 

and theres a couple different sites, since theres no 1 static list....

 

 

 

faber was never p4p? you guys really havent been following mma at all have you?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://www.411mania.com/MMA/columns/87287/411//s-MMA-Rankings-10.09.08:-Pound-For-Pound.htm

 

http://www.scoresreport.com/2008/10/27/mma-pound-for-pound-rankings/

 

^^^faber/torres

 

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/260645-september-pound-for-pound-rankings-the-song-remains-the-same

 

http://www.profighting-fans.com/rankings/pound-for-pound_020709.html

 

^^^^torres for a second year

 

and theres a couple different sites' date=' since theres no 1 static list....

 

 

 

faber was never p4p? you guys really havent been following mma at all have you?[/quote']

 

lol... The always reliable BleacherReport + 3 other sites I've never heard of. I could start a website and claim Cody McKenzie is P4P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://www.411mania.com/MMA/columns/87287/411//s-MMA-Rankings-10.09.08:-Pound-For-Pound.htm

 

http://www.scoresreport.com/2008/10/27/mma-pound-for-pound-rankings/

 

^^^faber/torres

 

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/260645-september-pound-for-pound-rankings-the-song-remains-the-same

 

http://www.profighting-fans.com/rankings/pound-for-pound_020709.html

 

^^^^torres for a second year

 

and theres a couple different sites' date=' since theres no 1 static list....

 

 

 

faber was never p4p? you guys really havent been following mma at all have you?[/quote']

 

I know he was listed but duh he's going to be listed thats a new division at the time and neither had beatin another P4P fighter, in my opinion to be P4P you have to beat other elite fighters at the time fabers best wins were the ones over a young Cruz and a washed up Jens Pulver.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know he was listed but duh he's going to be listed thats a new division at the time and neither had beatin another P4P fighter' date=' in my opinion to be P4P you have to beat other elite fighters at the time fabers best wins were the ones over a young Cruz and a washed up Jens Pulver.[/quote']

 

?????

 

 

how can u put silva on there then?

 

he hasnt beat any guys who have been p4p?

 

that logic is so bad its not even funny....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To be honest i don't really i think both GSP and Jones are ahead of Silva but Silva gets to 3rd because of he has been there so long.

 

GSP has beat 1 guy who was on that list....Penn

 

how does that put him on the list?

 

 

jones on the list? Pound for Pound list???

 

hes fighting in a smaller weight class!!!

 

 

w/e dude, im not gonna argue about that....

 

 

faber was P4P PERIOD

 

that was my point

Link to comment
Share on other sites

GSP has beat 1 guy who was on that list....Penn

 

how does that put him on the list?

 

 

jones on the list? Pound for Pound list???

 

hes fighting in a smaller weight class!!!

 

 

w/e dude' date=' im not gonna argue about that....

 

 

faber was P4P PERIOD

 

that was my point[/quote']

 

either way we straying from topic i don't think Aldo vs Edger will be one way traffic and just for clarification i hate P4P list it's pointless it's like trying to argue who's better Muhammad Ali or Suger Ray Robinson

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well' date=' someone who argued Edgar beat Bendo may argue that Sonnen beated Anderson.[/quote']

 

no offense but you have no clue, this is so dumb it's not even funny,

 

when a fight goes to a decision, it comes down to three people's opinions, and that's why it's easy to say Edgar won because a decision is all based on opinion

 

Sonnen tapped out, the fight didn't go to a decision, so you can't argue he beat him, how the **** does anyone argue that a guy won when he clearly tapped to stop the fight and say he lost?

 

So stupid.

 

 

back on topic - Edgar wins

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...