What in the world does Dana do if Penn vs. Edgar 2 is razor thin and Penn wins?

[CarlLane]

Title says it all, Penn wins the second even if it's not razor thin but say a solid 3-2 rounds for BJ does that warrant Edgar Penn III immediately?

[wingzero8717]

Title says it all' date=' Penn wins the second even if it's not razor thin but say a solid 3-2 rounds for BJ does that warrant Edgar Penn III immediately?[/quote']

 

I would think so but BJ will not let this fight go to a decision he will finish this time.

[Remedx]

i can only see another instant rematch if it's a shogun/machida type decision. even then it's a long shot. then again, who's really ready for a title shot? winner of maynard/florian, but if florian wins, that will be his third title shot, and he just got the second shot not too long ago.

 

but this is all hypothetical as Penn is going to finish Edgar within the first two rounds

[MysticKJ]

if there is a definitive 3 rounds to 2 for Penn then no immediate rematch...you just want to eliminate questionable decisions...

[Infamous505]

Penn wont let it go to decision so i will say the sub option, but that is a good question

[CarlLane]

I would think so but BJ will not let this fight go to a decision he will finish this time.

 

i'm with you on this, i think he'll finish it with a sub, prolly armbar

[ultimatefightingchamp]

Yup, no need to think about it. BJ is going to finish

[mangoKush]

it wont be razor thin cuz BJ is gona knock him out

[Nicodimus]

The last fight wasn't even close,Edgar owned BJ,period!

[AJ_Bearcat]

If BJ wins by close decision there would have to be an immediate rubber match.

[Pengu]

whoever wins the fight WILL face ken flo or gray for the title. thats the bottom line

[khaki_man]

I would think so but BJ will not let this fight go to a decision he will finish this time.

 

Agreed. BJ won't let Frankie bounce around like Richard f**king Simmons this time. He'll cut off the cage and knock Frankie out.

[XTHEBEASTX]

I think it all depends on how entertaining the fight is whether or not they wanna let it go to an instant rematch or not. If dana thinks he can squeeze more juice out of the lemon then im sure he will do it

[CaZz3000]

i think perhaps an early ref stoppage

happened with Aaron Riley vs Shane Nelson and now Mac Danzig vs Matt Wiman

x

[Rup]

that is a good question. instant rematches set bad precedents.

 

there is no way BJ is finishing edgar. I said it the 1st time around and i'll say it again. it will be another close 5 round decision. I expect both fighters to be better than they were in the 1st fight.

 

BTW for all the excuse makers out there. I just heard edgar went to the hospital after that fight for a staph infection. so there goes the BJ wasn't 100 percent arguement, cause neither was edgar, apparently.

[TeamEvans]

Penn will decisively. No need for a third.

[lsit6989_specv]

if there is a definitive 3 rounds to 2 for Penn then no immediate rematch...you just want to eliminate questionable decisions...

 

why was the last fight questionable? The judges gave the fight to Edgar, all 3....was it questionable because a bunch of fans dont think Edgar won?

 

if it is another close fight they should have a 3rd.

[Guessue24]

franky edgar is going to rape penn... again

[2cee]

I think bj is gonna pick him apart this fight. He landed the harder shots first fight. Dana will have tough decision if it is close though

[Guessue24]

I think bj is gonna pick him apart this fight. He landed the harder shots first fight. Dana will have tough decision if it is close though

 

well if ur talking dana u cant talk whats fair u have to talk what makes more money but if franky wins again by razor decision its set franky is the new champ, but if bj does seriosly who wants to see them fight again, it'll get really old